Readify

Lucien—Coralie

Illusions perdues

Lucien de Rubempré and Coralie are lovers whose relationship binds genuine devotion to the instability of Lucien’s public life. Coralie loves him and sacrifices herself for him, while he finds in her affection a refuge from the demands and failures of the world. Yet the intimacy does not protect either of them from the consequences of his ambition: his betrayal of a friend and his forged debt leave Coralie exposed to legal trouble, and her death finds him unable to pay for her burial.

Love amid Lucien’s ambitions

Coralie’s attachment is presented as more than a passing affair. Daniel d'Arthez, writing to Ève Séchard about Lucien’s conduct, describes Coralie as young, beautiful, and devoted to him, and says that her love obscures the dangers of the public life Lucien has chosen. From d'Arthez’s perspective, Lucien’s immediate pleasures keep him from seeing the social and personal risks of their situation. His criticism is directed at Lucien’s susceptibility to seduction and display, not at Coralie’s capacity to love.

The affair is also entangled with Lucien’s treatment of friendship. When Lucien brings d'Arthez the hostile criticism he has been ordered to publish against d'Arthez’s book, he confesses that he cannot bring himself to print it, despite the danger of disobeying his political party. D'Arthez understands that Lucien is choosing his mistress over his friend and helps him carry out that choice by correcting and approving the article. The episode gives the relationship a painful double meaning: Coralie’s love is real, but Lucien’s pursuit of its pleasures accompanies a betrayal that damages one of his closest friendships.

Support from the Séchard family

Lucien’s dependence reaches beyond Coralie. While Ève Séchard is recovering from childbirth, David Séchard tells her that Lucien is in terrible difficulty and that he has sent him three bills of one thousand francs, due at one, two, and three months. David leaves before Ève can ask him for an explanation. His practical response shows how Lucien’s troubles draw in the family even before they know the full circumstances of his life in Paris.

Concerned by Lucien’s long silence and troubling reports, Ève seeks the truth from Eugène de Rastignac. She learns of Lucien’s affair with Coralie, his duel with Michel Chrestien after betraying d'Arthez, and the loss of the protection of powerful people. Rastignac also tells her that Lucien has lost the decree granting him the name and arms of Rubempré, and that Louise de Bargeton, whom Lucien had left and insulted, has married Sixte du Châtelet. Ève is frightened by this account, but does not accept it without question: she writes to d'Arthez, seeking the judgment of someone who knows Lucien as a friend. Coralie’s place in the relationship thus emerges through conflicting testimony: Rastignac presents the affair among Lucien’s ruinous mistakes, while d'Arthez recognizes Coralie’s devotion even as he condemns Lucien’s choices.

Debt enters the household

The cost of Lucien’s conduct becomes concrete when legal proceedings reach Coralie’s home. On May 5, Lucien receives notice of a returned-bill account and protest from Angoulême, along with a summons to the Paris commercial court. Coralie does not understand the papers. She supposes that Lucien has helped his brother-in-law and gives him the documents too late. Her mistake reveals how little she knows about the financial danger surrounding him; her affection does not give her the information needed to intervene.

Lucien, by contrast, recognizes the fraud and feels ashamed. He pities David and wants to pay, but first seeks advice from his associates about how to gain time. A seizure follows, and officials attempt to remove Coralie’s furniture. The property is ultimately recognized as hers: after proceedings and an appeal, Métivier’s challenge is rejected. The contrast is stark. Coralie’s possessions can be legally distinguished from Lucien’s obligations, but she is still made to bear the fear and disruption of his crisis. Her innocence of the affair’s financial details is not the same as protection from its effects.

Coralie’s death and Lucien’s grief

In a letter dated August 29, Lucien tells Ève that Coralie died two days earlier, at five in the morning, and that he received her last breath. He describes her as one of God’s finest creatures and says that she had sacrificed everything for him. He believes she may have died for his sake, and says that she died as a Christian. These are Lucien’s words to his sister, written in grief; they present Coralie’s death as both the culmination of her devotion and an irreparable loss for him.

The letter’s most devastating fact is practical: Lucien says he has no money to bury her. The man who had pursued a brilliant and luxurious public life must now beg for the small sum required to place Coralie in consecrated ground. He turns to Ève and David as the people who may console him, just as he had once relied on Coralie for love and comfort. In a postscript, he adds that Camusot, the businessman he had caused serious trouble, has offered to settle the matter. When Ève shows the tear-stained letter to David, David pities Lucien, and Ève’s old affection for her brother becomes visible again. Coralie’s story in their relationship ends with her death, but its consequences continue to draw Lucien’s family into his distress.